Pie Season Is Open: The First Town of Babylon Bakers Taking Thanksgiving Orders |
Two Lindenhurst bakers and a West Babylon cake maker have posted their 2026 Thanksgiving menus: bourbon pecan and caramel brûlée pies, pudding pies in two sizes, and cookie kits to keep the kids busy. Here is what each one offers, when you can get it and how to order. |

BABYLON EATS · LINDENHURST · WEST BABYLON
Last week we went looking for Thanksgiving pie orders at the Town’s independent bakers and came up empty: nobody had posted a 2026 menu yet. This week the first ones are in. Three local bakers have posted 2026 menus on their own pages. More will follow, and your usual bakery may be taking orders at the counter, so call it too. Thanksgiving is Thursday, November 26.
A Mano Baking Company, Lindenhurst: five pies, delivered the day before. A Mano opened its 2026 Thanksgiving preorders on November 1. There are five pies at $30 each: Classic Apple, Apple Caramel Brûlée, Pumpkin, Pepe’s Famous Pecan, and a new Chocolate Kentucky Bourbon Pecan. Its prosciutto and provolone bread, stuffed cookies and granola are on the menu too. Thanksgiving orders are delivered Wednesday, November 25. No cutoff is posted, but delivery spots are limited and preorders sell out early, the bakery says. To order, send A Mano a direct message or email amanobakingcompany@gmail.com. Your order is confirmed only when you get a confirmation and payment instructions back. A Mano’s Thanksgiving post.
Custom Cakes by Kristy, Lindenhurst: nine flavors, two sizes, five pickup days. Kristy’s pie list runs from apple crumb, apple lattice, blueberry crumb, pecan and pumpkin to peanut butter mousse and chocolate, vanilla or Oreo pudding. A 9-inch pie is $30 and a 5-inch mini is $13. The fruit pies can be made vegan or gluten-free, from a shared kitchen. Pickup is in Lindenhurst, near American Venice: Saturday, Nov. 21, 9 a.m. to 3 p.m. and 7 to 9 p.m.; Sunday, Nov. 22, 9 a.m. to 9 p.m.; Tuesday, Nov. 24, 6 to 9 p.m.; Wednesday, Nov. 25, 6 to 8 p.m.; and Thanksgiving morning, 9 a.m. to 1 p.m. There is also a second pickup at The Hive Market in Oyster Bay for orders placed before Nov. 19. Delivery is limited. To reserve, message Custom Cakes by Kristy. Kristy’s pie post.
The Cake Tray, West Babylon: cake instead of pie, and something for the kids. The Cake Tray is baking Thanksgiving-themed 6-inch and 8-inch cakes, cupcakes and cake sickles, plus $20 cookie decorating kits (four cookies, frosting and sprinkles) for younger guests. Call or text 631-792-3305, or message The Cake Tray on Instagram or Facebook. No deadline is posted; the bakery asks you to order ahead. The Cake Tray’s Thanksgiving post.
Ordering dessert from a neighbor is an easy way to keep Small Business Season™ going. Is your bakery taking Thanksgiving orders? Email ryan@babylonlocal.com a link to your 2026 menu. For more around Town, see the I Love Babylon events calendar.
Sources: A Mano Baking Company, Thanksgiving 2026 menu, Nov. 1, 2026 · Custom Cakes by Kristy, “Pie Season Is Here,” Nov. 8, 2026 · The Cake Tray, “Thanksgiving Is Sweeter,” Nov. 4, 2026
Stock photo, not a Town of Babylon bakery's pie. Photo by Priscilla Du Preez 🇨🇦 on Unsplash. |

Nov 18, 2026
Babylon Local Business Class of 2026, Part 3: The Summer Openers
A food truck that finally found a home, a pizza family's second dining room, a luxury resale showroom, a new salon and a new therapy office on Main Street. Meet the locally owned businesses that opened in the Town of Babylon between July and September.

Nov 18, 2026
Thanksgiving Is Eight Days Away: What to Sign Up For, Book and Drop Off This Week
Turkey trot prices go up on race day, two Babylon Village dining rooms stop taking changes on Monday, the Town's own Thanksgiving help starts with a phone call, and a coat drive at Town Hall just opened. Here is the to-do list before the holiday week arrives.

Nov 18, 2026
"You Gonna Keep Me Waitin'?" Pibbles, Shelter No. 39, Has Something to Say
I been sittin' here since March 4. I'm spayed, I'm chipped, I'm thirty-five bucks. So what's the holdup?

Nov 18, 2026
Let Someone Else Carve: Three Babylon Village Thanksgiving Tables, and Why Monday Matters
A carving-station buffet on Deer Park Avenue, a three-course prix fixe up the street, and an a la carte dinner on Fire Island Avenue. Two of them lock in your reservation on Monday, November 23.


0 Comments
Join the conversation
Be the first to comment
Share your thoughts above.