Town of Babylon
Advertisement Advertisement
Breaking News
Let Someone Else Carve: Three Babylon Village Thanksgiving Tables, and Why Monday Matters
A carving-station buffet on Deer Park Avenue, a three-course prix fixe up the street, and an a la carte dinner on Fire Island Avenue. Two of them lock in your reservation on Monday, November 23.
Ryan Williams

Ryan Williams

Nov 18, 2026

0 Comments

BABYLON EATS · BABYLON VILLAGE

 

If this is the year nobody wants to wrestle the bird, three Babylon Village dining rooms will cook Thanksgiving dinner for you on Thursday, November 26. Two of them want a credit card when you reserve, and both stop taking changes or cancellations on Monday, November 23. If you’re on the fence, decide this week.

 

The buffet: Lily’s Babylon, 345 Deer Park Avenue. The pub, which pairs American food with Irish pub fare, sets out a Thanksgiving buffet with a carving station, salads, the traditional sides and a dessert station. There are two seatings, at 2 p.m. and 4:30 p.m. The price is $59 a person and $29 for children, plus tax and gratuity. Reservations are required; call 631-539-0816.

 

The prix fixe: The Argyle Grill & Tavern, 90 Deer Park Avenue. A few blocks south, the Argyle serves a three-course prix fixe: a starter, an entrée and dessert. Seatings start at 1 p.m. It is $125 per adult and $39 per child, plus tax and gratuity, and you book through the restaurant’s website. The Argyle hasn’t posted the dishes. Lily’s and the Argyle are sister restaurants in the same local group, so the same Monday rule applies to both.

 

The a la carte table: The James, 21 Fire Island Avenue. The James is taking Thanksgiving reservations with seatings between noon and 6 p.m. Instead of a set holiday menu, it serves its regular a la carte dinner menu plus chef’s specials, which works if half your table doesn’t want turkey. The James hasn’t posted holiday prices. Call 631-975-2637.

 

Eating at home? We looked for independent Town of Babylon restaurants, delis and markets taking take-home Thanksgiving dinner orders. As of Tuesday, none had posted a menu or an order deadline on its own site. If you’re taking orders, send us the page at ryan@babylonlocal.com and we’ll add you next week. For dessert, last week’s pie guide has the local bakers and their order dates.

 

Sources: Lily’s Babylon, reservations and Thanksgiving buffet flyer · The Argyle Grill & Tavern, reservations and Thanksgiving flyer · The James, Babylon

 

Stock photo, not a Babylon Village restaurant's Thanksgiving dinner. Photo by Monstera Production on Pexels.

0 Comments

Join the conversation

Be the first to comment

Share your thoughts above.

More from Babylon Local