Still Here: The Post Office Café Has Been Delivering on West Main Street for Nearly 50 Years |
Jack Lessing bought Babylon's old post office in 1978, when a bartending school was using it, and turned it into a family pub. The Lessing family still runs it, and regulars still treat it like the place where everybody meets. |

FEATURED BUSINESS · BABYLON VILLAGE
Babylon Village has a post office where nobody has bought a stamp in about 50 years.
The Post Office Café at 130 West Main Street really was Babylon’s post office. According to the restaurant’s own history, Jack Lessing bought the building in 1978 from a friend who was running a bartending school inside, and turned it into a family pub. Greater Long Island reported in 2017 that the building served as a post office from the 1930s to the 1970s.
The pub did something new for its time. In Suffolk County, bars, diners and restaurants were separate places, and the Post Office helped break that mold, building what would later be called a bar and grill or gastropub, Greater Long Island wrote at its 40th anniversary in 2018. The Lessing family has since opened many more restaurants, but the PO on West Main Street was its first on Long Island, and it is the one this story is about.
It is still a family operation. At that anniversary, Michael Lessing was president of the family’s restaurant company, and Mark Lessing, its executive vice president, had once tended bar and managed the PO. “Our Post Office team is the reason why we’re still around today,” Michael Lessing said.
The room got its first full makeover in September 2017: a new brick facade, fireplaces and beach-scene art. Some of the carousel horses and menagerie animals regulars knew stayed put.
The founders put it best on the restaurant’s site. “People don’t come to us because they’re hungry,” Jack and Larry Lessing wrote. “They come for company and companionship.”
What to get: the restaurant says it is known for its burgers and craft cocktails. Call 631-669-9224 before you go.
This is Small Business Season™. Know a Town of Babylon business that has outlasted everyone around it? Tell us at ryan@babylonlocal.com, and we will feature it here.
Sources: Post Office Café, “Our Story” · Greater Long Island, “Post Office to celebrate 40th anniversary,” Oct. 4, 2018 · Greater Long Island, “Post Office Cafe gets a makeover after nearly four decades in Babylon,” Sept. 9, 2017
Post Office Café's bar and dining room in Babylon. Post Office Café. |

Nov 18, 2026
Babylon Local Business Class of 2026, Part 3: The Summer Openers
A food truck that finally found a home, a pizza family's second dining room, a luxury resale showroom, a new salon and a new therapy office on Main Street. Meet the locally owned businesses that opened in the Town of Babylon between July and September.

Nov 18, 2026
Thanksgiving Is Eight Days Away: What to Sign Up For, Book and Drop Off This Week
Turkey trot prices go up on race day, two Babylon Village dining rooms stop taking changes on Monday, the Town's own Thanksgiving help starts with a phone call, and a coat drive at Town Hall just opened. Here is the to-do list before the holiday week arrives.

Nov 18, 2026
"You Gonna Keep Me Waitin'?" Pibbles, Shelter No. 39, Has Something to Say
I been sittin' here since March 4. I'm spayed, I'm chipped, I'm thirty-five bucks. So what's the holdup?

Nov 18, 2026
Let Someone Else Carve: Three Babylon Village Thanksgiving Tables, and Why Monday Matters
A carving-station buffet on Deer Park Avenue, a three-course prix fixe up the street, and an a la carte dinner on Fire Island Avenue. Two of them lock in your reservation on Monday, November 23.


0 Comments
Join the conversation
Be the first to comment
Share your thoughts above.