After 31 Years of Café Il Villaggio, a New Italian Name Waits on Deer Park Avenue |
The Domingo family served its last dinner at 35 Deer Park Ave. in April, and kept the house dressing recipe. State records now show a company called Natalia's Italian American Cuisine at the same address. Here is what the family left, and what we know about what comes next. |

MAIN STREET · BABYLON VILLAGE
Some restaurants close and are forgotten by the next season. Café Il Villaggio is not one of them.
For 31 years the family-owned Italian restaurant at 35 Deer Park Ave. was run by Lucie Domingo, her husband, chef Mike Domingo, and her sister, Josephine Mannina. Its last dinner was Friday, April 24, Patch reported.
The reason was simple and human. “Mike keeps telling me my mind is telling me to continue but my bones are not up to it,” Lucie Domingo told Greater Long Island. “So we decided it’s time to sit back and relax.”
What she remembered was the people. “When we first opened more than three decades ago, everyone came in as customers looking for a good meal,” she said. “But they became family.” The restaurant’s farewell post put it the same way: a small restaurant “where strangers walked in and left as lifelong friends.”
Most of the recipes are staying in the family. Regulars asked for the house dressing, she said, and “we are keeping that one!”
What comes next on the corner. The business was sold, and a new restaurant was expected to take the space, GLI reported in April. In September, Long Island Wave found state records for a new company, Natalia’s Italian American Cuisine, organized in August and listed at 35 Deer Park Ave. The name says the cuisine is staying Italian. Nothing else is public yet: no owner, no menu, no opening date.
We will keep watching the windows on Deer Park Avenue. If you are behind Natalia’s, or you have a favorite Il Villaggio memory to share, write to us at ryan@babylonlocal.com.
Sources: Patch, April 23, 2026 · Greater Long Island, “End of an era as Café Il Villaggio closes,” April 2026 · Long Island Wave, Sept. 30, 2026
Stock photo, not Café Il Villaggio or Natalia's. Photo by Klaus Nielsen on Pexels. |

Nov 18, 2026
Babylon Local Business Class of 2026, Part 3: The Summer Openers
A food truck that finally found a home, a pizza family's second dining room, a luxury resale showroom, a new salon and a new therapy office on Main Street. Meet the locally owned businesses that opened in the Town of Babylon between July and September.

Nov 18, 2026
Thanksgiving Is Eight Days Away: What to Sign Up For, Book and Drop Off This Week
Turkey trot prices go up on race day, two Babylon Village dining rooms stop taking changes on Monday, the Town's own Thanksgiving help starts with a phone call, and a coat drive at Town Hall just opened. Here is the to-do list before the holiday week arrives.

Nov 18, 2026
"You Gonna Keep Me Waitin'?" Pibbles, Shelter No. 39, Has Something to Say
I been sittin' here since March 4. I'm spayed, I'm chipped, I'm thirty-five bucks. So what's the holdup?

Nov 18, 2026
Let Someone Else Carve: Three Babylon Village Thanksgiving Tables, and Why Monday Matters
A carving-station buffet on Deer Park Avenue, a three-course prix fixe up the street, and an a la carte dinner on Fire Island Avenue. Two of them lock in your reservation on Monday, November 23.


0 Comments
Join the conversation
Be the first to comment
Share your thoughts above.