“We Will Rebuild”: Tricia’s American Cafe Plans Its Return to Babylon Village |
Two weeks after the Oct. 28 fire, the family behind Tricia’s says it will rebuild, though the timeline is still unclear. Customers can follow along, and help, through a fundraiser the restaurant shared itself. |

MAIN STREET · BABYLON VILLAGE
Last week we wrote about what Tricia’s American Cafe at 26 E. Main St. has meant to Babylon Village over 29 years, and said there was no word yet on what came next after the early-morning fire of Oct. 28. Now there is.
“We will rebuild and look forward to seeing everyone soon,” the restaurant posted on Instagram on Saturday, Nov. 7, thanking “our customers and Babylon friends and neighbors” for their support. The family was candid about the rest: the timeline is still unclear, and they are “hoping for the best.”
Two days after the fire, the restaurant’s Facebook page shared a fundraiser, “Help Tricia’s Cafe Rebuild,” with a note that it pained them to ask. “We love all our Customers and want to be able to serve you again,” it read. As of Tuesday evening the fundraiser showed $7,300 raised toward a $20,000 goal, from 67 donations.
In an update posted there, the family thanked everyone who has given or sent messages, and explained where things stand: they are still waiting for the insurance companies to decide who will handle what in rebuilding the structural damage. The writer’s father, the update says, will post progress on the restaurant’s Instagram and Facebook pages every week.
For a room where so many families marked birthdays and Friday nights, the waiting is the hard part. If you want to help, sharing the fundraiser counts too, the family says; and if you just miss the place, the updates are where to look. We will keep watching for a reopening date.
Sources: Tricia’s American Cafe on Instagram, Nov. 7, 2026 · Tricia’s American Cafe on Facebook, Oct. 30, 2026 · GoFundMe, “Help Tricia’s Cafe Rebuild” · Patch, Oct. 30, 2026 · Babylon Local, Issue 7
Tricia's American Cafe dining room, before the fire. Tricia's American Cafe. |

Nov 18, 2026
Babylon Local Business Class of 2026, Part 3: The Summer Openers
A food truck that finally found a home, a pizza family's second dining room, a luxury resale showroom, a new salon and a new therapy office on Main Street. Meet the locally owned businesses that opened in the Town of Babylon between July and September.

Nov 18, 2026
Thanksgiving Is Eight Days Away: What to Sign Up For, Book and Drop Off This Week
Turkey trot prices go up on race day, two Babylon Village dining rooms stop taking changes on Monday, the Town's own Thanksgiving help starts with a phone call, and a coat drive at Town Hall just opened. Here is the to-do list before the holiday week arrives.

Nov 18, 2026
"You Gonna Keep Me Waitin'?" Pibbles, Shelter No. 39, Has Something to Say
I been sittin' here since March 4. I'm spayed, I'm chipped, I'm thirty-five bucks. So what's the holdup?

Nov 18, 2026
Let Someone Else Carve: Three Babylon Village Thanksgiving Tables, and Why Monday Matters
A carving-station buffet on Deer Park Avenue, a three-course prix fixe up the street, and an a la carte dinner on Fire Island Avenue. Two of them lock in your reservation on Monday, November 23.


0 Comments
Join the conversation
Be the first to comment
Share your thoughts above.