The Old Gemelli Space Is About to Be a Diner Again |
A Farmingdale family with 45 years in Long Island diners takes over 175 E. Main Street. |
BABYLON EATS · BABYLON VILLAGE
The long-empty Ristorante Gemelli space at 175 E. Main Street is about to reopen as a diner, and the family behind it has been in this business a long time.
Whiskey Down Diner is expected to open its second location in Babylon Village later this month. Greater Long Island toured the space last week.
It is roughly double the size of the original Farmingdale restaurant — a bigger dining room, high ceilings, an outdoor patio, and a bar set in the middle of the floor rather than pushed against a wall.
“The bar is right in the middle … it’s awesome,” co-owner Alyson Kanaras told Greater Long Island.
For her, Babylon was the point.
“I always wanted to be in Babylon. I live in Babylon. I love it there,” she said.
Whiskey Down was founded by Alyson and her siblings, John and Kristina. Their father, Peter Kanaras, has owned the Olympic Diner in Deer Park since 1980 — it is where their parents met and where the three of them learned the business.
“I am a diner girl through and through,” she has said.
The family spent about two years building the concept before the first location opened in Farmingdale in June 2019: a shorter menu, elevated comfort food, and far more attention to the bar than a traditional diner gives it.
The Babylon deal took its own two years of conversation before the lease was signed in December. Construction started in April.
The menu, she said, is not changing.
“I want the menu to be the same and just translate right over to Babylon,” Kanaras said.
Sources: Greater Long Island · Whiskey Down Diner |
Sep 23, 2026
Nineteen Things to Do This Weekend
A family festival at Tanner Park runs all three days, three farmers markets, and a 60th birthday run at Belmont Lake.
Sep 23, 2026
Namleps Lane Does This for People It Loves
James Hentschel has done Ozzy, Hulk Hogan and 9/11. In September he did Dolly.
Sep 23, 2026
The Town Is Making a Case Against the Perfect Lawn
Green Homes ran native-plant workshops with an ecological landscaper, and the argument is about stormwater.
Sep 23, 2026
The Basement in Babylon That Built Long Island Surfing
Sixty years of Bunger Surf, the 1962 championship at Gilgo, and the gallery show that put it on the walls.


0 Comments
Join the conversation
Be the first to comment
Share your thoughts above.